Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Musings about Swarms and Trap Hives: Getting “Free-bees”



Most people don’t mind getting freebies—getting something for nothing. Beekeepers aren’t the exception. They always need to find ways to save a bit of money with their beekeeping. 

Whether it is just a hobby or a full business, it can be expensive. Sometimes it’s like that bee vac, except it sucks up your money. So free bees are usually welcomed and one of the ways to get them is through the use of trap hives to catch swarms.

 My bee partner Marcos hanging a swarm trap in one of the shade trees used on his coffee farm. We started an apiary together a number of years ago, filling all the hives by catching swarms. The first dozen gave us enough honey that year to make us a bit of a profit.


Although this blog post focuses on how I use trap hives (or swarm traps/swarm boxes) in conjunction with my top bar hives (tbhs) and with the Africanized bees  in Honduras, the basic principles will work for whatever style of beekeeping or hive boxes. It’s a matter of taking the general ideas into consideration and adapting them to your own beekeeping situation. 

The Why of Swarms and Trap Hives 

Swarm traps are my preferred way of increasing my hive count and replacing those colonies that for whatever reason I lose. The Africanized bees  of Honduras give me an advantage since they like to swarm more than other races of honeybees. Swarms are plentiful during certain times of the year and easy to obtain using trap hives. 

But at the same time, the Africanized bees’ defensive behavior and my preference for top bar hives made it a challenge to find a system that works for me and my beekeeping. Trial and error got me to a point where I have something that functions well and with which I’m happy.

I could also make splits to increase my number of hives, but that involves getting into the brood area. That is when the Africanized bees will really get upset. Normally you also need to find the queen. Africanized queens can be elusive—they like to run and having riled up bees doesn’t help to locate them.


A swarm moving into the trap hive in the mango tree behind my house. Every year I was assured of getting one or two swarms in this tree.

Swarms just about always stay when they move into the trap hive on their own. I have very little luck shaking swarms out of a tree in Honduras. They usually take off the next day, even if I give them a couple combs with brood and honey. This is one of the characteristics of Africanized bees.

An added advantage is that swarms can also introduce genetic diversity into your apiary, especially if the bees come from a survivor hive that has gone untreated for years. If the swarm happens to come from one of your own hives, it helps lessen the sting of the possible setback in the honey production. And the swarms hit the ground running, often building up fast.

Trap hive design considerations

In general, honeybees are not that particular about where they will nest or the type of box you give them. If you think about the places where you find wild colonies, it makes you realize they can adapt to different cavities. You can find them in hollow trees, in walls, in roofs, and in the ground. I even saw one that had moved underneath a sofa someone had in storage. There are also the occasional open-air colonies.

Any type of box can potentially be used as a trap hive. However, I wanted to find something that would work well for me with my beekeeping situation and beekeeping style—something that was functional, inexpensive, and problem free.

Top bar hives and compatible dimensions. All my bee colonies are in top bar hives, mainly the trapezoidal Kenyan top bar hives but also the rectangular Tanzanian top bar hives. They are both a very inexpensive system to use and they also help me to control the Africanized bees a bit more. I wanted to design a trap hive that would function with my tbh system. I also wanted to avoid having to cut out the comb from the trap hive box and tie it to top bars, like you do when removing wild colonies.

So I made a smaller version of my tbh boxes. I kept the same dimensions so the combs would fit and smoothly transfer into the permanent boxes. 


Most of my trap hives are trapezoidal shaped, with the same dimensions as the permanent tbh boxes. But I also have some rectangular-shaped top bar hives and make some trap hives with their measurements.

My trapezoidal swarm boxes have ten bars across the top, but only eight of these are useable by the bees for comb building. The ones at either end are used to snug the rest of the bars together and then are nailed into the end pieces of the box. The rectangular-style tbh trap hives are a bit narrower—nine top bars across the top of which seven were usable for comb building.

These sizes have worked very well for me. The swarms in Honduras readily move into them. Some beekeepers talk about using a five-frame nuc box as a trap hive—too small in my opinion. But at the same time I wouldn’t go with anything bigger than ten bars. There is the added bulkiness for hanging it and the added weight for lowering and moving it to the apiary if the swarms fills it fast.


My trapezoidal swarm boxes are made to the width of ten top bars. The outer two bars snug the others together and are nailed into the end pieces of the box. This leaves the bees eight bars from which they can build comb. It is then covered with plastic for rain and to seal up the top. The crisscrossed stings are attached to some bent-over nails and used to hang the traps (and carry them!).

Light weight boxes. I usually have to carry my trap hives a good distance, maybe even several hundred meters. The terrain in Honduras often does not permit a truck to be driven close to where the traps are hung or where the apiary is located. It can be rugged and steep. Carrying a heavy box can get uncomfortable. Thus I like to incorporate light-weight materials such as aluminum printing-press plates, plastic and tin cans with the sturdier wooden parts of the box—something to help cut the weight.

A large swarm can easily fill the box with combs and brood within two or three weeks. This means there will be an even larger amount of weight to take down from the tree and to carry to the bee yard. That doesn’t help the beekeeper, especially if you need to lower the trap from a precarious position up in the tree and then carry it up or down a steep hillside. Also, you sometimes need to remove the trap from the tree by yourself without a helper.

The rugged terrain of Honduras can make hanging and moving trap hives a chore, especially if it’s heavy with bees. Here Marcos (right) and I are making the rounds to hang swarm traps on his coffee farm, where we have an apiary together. The crisscrossed strings over the top make nice carrying handles. 

Bee containment. The swarm boxes needed to be sealed in such a way that bees would not escape when transporting them. Africanized bees have rightfully won their reputation for being ornery. They will look for any small hole through which they can escape and then sting the beekeeper. 

There are enough other added obstacles with taking the traps out of the tree and then moving them in the dark (I wait until all the bees have entered for the night). I don’t want to have to deal with angry escaping bees and also avoid tripping over tree roots or rocks as I climb up a steep slope in order to get the box to the path or out to the road. And in some ways the bees are worse at night because they will crawl on you and not fly. You leave with those bees clinging to you, waiting for their chance to sting you.

I use plastic to cover the top and keep out the rain. The plastic also helps to seal the area around the top bars and ensures they do not come loose or shift when moving the trap. The only holes in the box should be the two entrances, one on either side. These are easily plugged by stuffing a piece of sponge into them.


Trap hives filled with bees, waiting to be moved to their new home. These were actually taken down the night before and moved to the apiary the following morning. One of the boxes was leaking bees so it got put into a feed sack.

Hanging the traps. A piece of string is crisscrossed over the top to help hang the swarm box. This string is attached to some bent-over nails that I put in the top corners of the trap. The main hanging rope is tied to where these cross each other.

As an added bonus, this gives me a nice handle for carrying the box.

Low cost. I wanted to keep the trap hives inexpensive. This was both because of limited financial resources and also because of theft. If one of the boxes would be stolen or vandalized (which has happened), the loss would be as minimal as possible. Most of the materials are recycled or used. Losing the top bars is what usually hurts the most if someone takes one of the traps—I buy new wood to make them.


Vandalism can occur to the trap hives. My guess is that someone took a long branch and decided to poke the side of the box. I normally try to hang the box within sight of someone’s house. I also try to hang it in a way that it won’t be so obvious to someone passing by.

Multiple uses. The boxes can also be used if you make splits or nucs. They are useful for removing/shaking a swarm from a tree. They work well for transporting honeycombs that I will sell as cut comb. And they also work well as an improvised chair or work bench!

Baiting the trap hives

The trap hive needs to be baited to increase your chances of catching a swarm. To help attract the scout bees, I liberally sprinkle melted wax inside the box. I usually use clean rendered wax but melting old dark combs is an effective alternative. I do not put old combs inside the box since wax moths would readily find them. They are a year-round problem here. 

The outside is baited with lemon grass, which is commonly grown in the backyards of many Honduran homes. One way I’ve applied it is by making a very strong tea and painting the outside of the box with it. Hondurans make a tea to drink, using two or three blades of grass (and sweetened with honey!). I take a good fistful to make my bait tea. I have also taken a clump of the grass and rubbed it onto the box, to the point where I see green.


Marcos with the hedge of lemon grass we planted on his coffee farm. I usually bait the traps by rubbing lemon grass on the outside until I see green. Melted wax gets splattered on the inside. Boxes that have already been occupied by bees work the best—they have a good bee odor.

I like to use top bars that have a ridge of comb, either from having been harvested or maybe from old comb that I removed. It all helps to attract the swarm and make them stay.

The boxes are rebaited with lemon grass every other week or when I make the rounds to check them. I don’t usually need to rebait the traps that have had bees in them previously. They have residues of wax and propolis and a strong bee smell. Maybe I will just rub a bit of lemon grass on the outside before hanging them.

Choosing the trees for the trap.

I’m not a good tree climber so I usually look for a tree with some low branches so I can get up into it. I remember as a boy how my two brothers could swing themselves up into our maple trees without a problem, leaving me down below to face their taunts. Better yet is if I can find a tree with a suitable branch that I can just reach while standing on the ground. 

I usually make the rounds on my scooter so carrying a ladder is out of the question. And it’s just uncomfortable lugging the ladder around, because of the rugged terrain and the distance often associated with where I hang the boxes. I would rather carry two swarm traps at a time rather than one and a ladder.


Trap hive in a mango tree. This one was easy to climb and had good branches for hanging the trap hive.

Swarms seem to favor some types of trees more than others, for whatever reason. Fruit trees have worked well for me, especially mango trees. Their branches usually make climbing and placement of the traps easy. Orange trees are also good but the spines on their branches make placement a bit trickier and difficult. 

On the coffee farm, I like to use the guama trees they use as shade, even though their branches make placement more difficult. They spread out in such a way that it’s harder to find a place where the trap can easily be hung but also stay steady in a wind. Down in the valley the jicaro trees and their tangle of branches work especially well (and they’re easy to climb also!). I have not had much luck in pine or oak trees. 



 Trap hive in a jicaro tree.

What I have seen is that the trees which catch a swarm will work year after year. In some particular trees I have caught as many as five swarms in one season, hanging up one box after another as they get filled.

I try not to choose a tree that is in the very middle of woods. I prefer the tree to be on the edge of a field or other open area. You want the scout bees to easily find the box.

Ideally the tree is also within sight of a house so someone can keep an eye on the trap. Kids are curious and have messed with my swarm boxes. Some limbs and leaves to camouflage them are good.

Hanging the trap hive.

What goes up has to come down. Hanging the trap hive is usually the easy part. Removing it when there is a swarm inside can be difficult. Take this into consideration.

Ideally l like to hang the trap about ten or twelve feet up in the tree. This is out of reach (and usually out of sight) of kids from the ground. It is also high enough so the eventual bees in them will not easily bother (or be bothered by) cattle or horses that may be on the ground below the box. But at the same time, trap hives hung lower, maybe only six or seven feet above the ground, will also work. Africanized bees don’t seem to be that fussy. I’ve caught swarms in extra trap hives that were setting on the ground behind my house.



My traps hive usually hang freely from their rope. At the same time, I try to rest them against a limb or the tree trunk so they don’t move in the wind. The rope used to hang them is thrown over a branch above them and tied off down below where I can reach it from the ground. I tied this one off on a nail I pounded into the tree.

I try to hang them so they can be easily lowered. A large swarm can easily fill a box within two weeks, making it quite heavy. It can be difficult and awkward to remove it, especially when one is trying to maintain his or her own balance while standing on a tree limb. 

I usually let the trap hive hang somewhat freely, only resting against a branch to minimize movement in a wind. If necessary, it could even be tied against the branch to help keep it more stable. I don’t set it on a limb or in the crotch of a tree. All the weight is supported from the crossed ropes over the top of the box. The main support rope is thrown over a branch above the trap and tied off down below in an easily accessible place. After stuffing the entrance, I basically just need to untie this rope and lower the trap to the ground.

You could set the trap in the crotch of a tree but it sometimes causes problems for the removal. Although the trap will stay steady, it will be necessary to lift it up and out of the crotch to remove it. This can be difficult with a heavy trap or if you only have one hand available (the other is around a branch so you don’t fall).



An example of what not to do with a trap hive. A big swarm moved into this box that got set into the crotch of a tree. The trap was nice and stable but the weight of the bees and their comb building after a couple weeks actually wedged it in there. It didn’t want to come out of the crotch and the slippery bark of this tree didn’t help us. We actually ended up having some combs collapse in this one that night.

Removing the trap hive from the tree.

I usually like to leave the trap hive up in the trees with the swarm for a week or two. Since Africanized bees like to abscond more readily than European bees, I don’t want to disturb the swarm until they get established with comb and brood. When they are at this point I have no problems with them wanting to take off. They normally have enough space in my swarm boxes to hold them for three or so weeks.

The only thing you should need to do is stuff something into the entrances and then lower it down. Always be prepared with a veil, even though you may not need it. I usually have my simple mosquito-net string veil down around my neck, ready to pull up if necessary. You may also want to have your smoker lit and ready, for whatever emergency. Sometimes a group of bees will be hanging outside the entrance and smoke will be necessary to coax them inside.

One person can lower the trap hive by himself, especially if enough extra rope was used and it was hung in a way to make this simple. Two people usually make the work easier. For example, if the rope is long enough, the person on the ground can lower the box (an extra piece can be tied to it if more would be needed). The person above in the tree guides the trap, maybe swinging it out a bit to avoid branches below it. When within reach from the ground, the person in the tree grabs the main rope while the person below will grab the trap in his or her hands to lower it the final distance to the ground.



Marcos stuffing a sponge into the entrance of the trap hive. The box was sealed up except for the entrances on each side. I try to hang the trap hives in a way that makes taking them out of the tree easy. Although Marcos could stand comfortably on this limb to reach the swarm trap, he only had one hand available to close up the hive and help lower it.

Finally, the trap hive and its bees are taken to the apiary and placed on a hive stand where they will permanently stay.

Use care to avoid combs breaking in top bar trap hives. There are no frames to support the combs. Lower the hive carefully and carry it gently to the bee yard. Large swarms cause more problems than small ones. Within a week or two, a large swarm can have full combs built, heavy with brood. One bad bump can cause these new combs to collapse, making a mess and possibly killing the queen in the process.

Finally, don’t forget to open the entrance once it is located in its place in the apiary.

Transfer to their permanent box.

I again wait at least a week before transferring the bees into their permanent hive. I want them to get used to being in the new location. The transfer is a rather simple process. Basically all the combs are lifted out of the trap hive and placed into the permanent box. It takes more time to set up the permanent box than it does to move the combs over to it.



The transfer of the new hive into its permanent box is usually a simple process—lift the combs out (two at a time in this case) and pass them into the bee’s new home. I always try to keep the combs in the same order at this point. I don’t specifically look for the queen but I do check the brood and its pattern.

---Tom


Comments are always welcomed. Let me know what you do with your trap hives or what you think of my system. I’m always open to answering questions. 

If you found my blog post about swarm traps useful, please share it.

14 comments:

  1. Wonderful post Tom! I had heard that killing the queen after catching an African swarm helped in them not swarm a second time. Have you heard this or tried it? Do you find just that extra time in the swarm box helps that transition to their final tbh? Thanks in advance.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Saludos Megan.

    I’m glad you enjoyed the post.

    I haven’t heard that about killing the queen. In some ways it makes sense but it makes me think about their need to raise a new queen then. Just to have you clarify your comment, are you referring to swarms you shake out of a tree or those that move into a bait box? I’ve never seen bees that have moved into my bait box swarm again—unless they stay in there long enough to fill everything up completely. It’s the shook swarms that usually abscond on me.

    If the Africanized swarm moves into my swarm box it will just about always stay. And that extra time does help. If they start to make brood they’re mine. This also includes staying after the eventual transfer to their permanent tbh.

    I find the ahb to be kind of delicate in regards to absconding. The same sort of thing happens if they are getting low on stores during the dearth. They’re going to take off for another area rather than sit around and starve to death.

    Do the beekeepers in Grenada use swarm traps? If so, what do they use for the boxes and how do they go about it? Is there a healthy population of wild colonies? In Honduras there is and also in the part of Jamaica where I spent most of my time. Take care.

    ---Tom

    ReplyDelete
  3. Really enjoyed seeing how you are catching your swarms as well as working with the character of the bees in your area. The bees here are also regarded as Africanized but I would still like to try catching some free bees to start a hive. My first batch did not stay and already you have given me a lot to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Timingisperfect, I’m glad you found my post useful. Hopefully there is something in it that will make your new intent at beekeeping successful. I’m curious about where you’re located since you have Africanized bees also.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tom, I'm in Phoenix Arizona and from what I read all of our bees should be considered Africanized. Our previous bees were ferals that we tried to hive and they were remarkably gentle for the process. But the colony was very small and there was no brood to defend (new queen not laying yet, assuming there was a queen).

    I've looked into the average temp highs in Honduras and it seems that you enjoy a very nice climate. Do you think a top bar hive would be viable in 115 degrees? It seems like such a good solution to only expose one frame at a time.

    We've got some new bait hives out and as per your suggestion have put melted down old comb in them and a little lemongrass oil. Hopefully it is enticing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It should work. Just be careful when you go into the hive—late in the afternoon or early in the morning when the temperature is cooler. You also may want to think about keeping it in a bit of shade. If bees have access to water, they can regulate the temperature of the hive.

      Usually all my comb collapse is my fault. In general, the climate is nice here but there are certain times of the year when it can get very warm and dry. Not 115 but hot enough where I work carefully.

      Good luck with the bait hives.

      Delete
  6. Hola from Texas!

    Thank you for the posts! I am doing some research into Africanized bees and the information provided was exactly what I was looking for!

    Just curious, one of the things I read was that bee keepers in Africa will take a moist towel and when collecting honey will cover the opening created by the bar they removed from the KTBH. It was suggested that it helped to control the flow of bees and it helped to calm them down some. What are your views on this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Saludos Texas. I’m glad that you found my posts useful. That’s one of the reasons I started this blog. When you said thanks for the “posts,” I hope that included the three I wrote a while back specifically about Africanized bees and working with them.

      It makes sense the moist towel would help to keep them calm. It’s one less space where the bees can continue to fly out of while you are cutting the honey comb into the bucket or filling up the smoker with more fuel. I’ve noticed when I sometimes leave a space opened up on the top bar hive while I do something else for a moment, the bees start coming out and accumulating around that exposed area. I then have all these extra bees on the outside to deal with and brush back into the box.

      It’s something a beekeeper would need to try out and see if it helps enough to always do that or if it becomes bothersome to continually cover up that space for a moment while checking and working the hives.

      Delete
    2. Tom, yes I was speaking of all the articles but especially the ones on working Africanized bees. Call it research in to what to expect if I end up with a swarm of them. lol

      Delete
  7. Kia Ora Tom,

    Paul from New Zealand here. I am wondering about the relocating of the bait hive from the tree that you caught the swarm in to your apiary... if it is less than 5km (3 miles) do you need to shift the hive slowly, or do they transfer to their new apiary without problem?

    Thanks for your article, Paul

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Saludos Paul.

      It can be a problem when the trap hives is in the area of the bee yard and it’s going to stay in that apiary. Ideally I will move it permanently to another bee yard that is outside of the area the bees know, but that’s not always possible. Usually it’s a time issue—it’s either take it out of the tree now or wait several more days (or a week even).

      Moving it a bit at a time over several nights doesn’t make sense. Moving it 10 yards a night isn’t feasible when the distance is several hundred yards to the apiary.

      Moving it out of the area temporarily and then bringing it back again means two trips. I’m not going to do that, especially if it’s up the mountain on the coffee farm where road is normally very rough. There’ll be too much comb breakage with my tbh swarm traps.

      Often the best option (or only option) is to simply move it to the apiary and accept that some bees will return the next morning to the tree where the trap hive was hanging. Lost bees, I call them. I usually try to stuff a bit of grass loosely in the entrance or put some sort of leafy plants outside the entrance so part of the bees will maybe reorient themselves to the new location. It doesn’t work for all the bees however. I might actually lose around a half pound to a pound of bees. Even after two weeks you might still see some bees hanging out on that tree.

      I don’t like to lose bees like this but sometimes there’s no other option. I just have to accept it (but also realize the colony will continue to grow and eventually replace those lost bees). It’s not nice but you can’t always do what is perfect.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for that info Tom. I thought that might be the case, and would rather not lose bees, but imagine that if I have any success with my bait hives in the coming spring, that is exactly what will happen. Still, it's better than not catching any swarms! Cheers, Paul

      Delete
  8. Very nice blog.

    I wondered why your swarm hives (the rectangular as well?) have two entrances. Ventilation maybe? Would you recommend two entrances for bait hives with Langstroth frames?

    Pieter
    Curaçao

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Saludos Pieter,

      Basically, I figured that having the extra entrance at the opposite side would help the bees to find their way inside to check out the trap, especially since the entrances aren’t that big. I haven’t seen anything negative from it. I just can’t forget to seal up the second entrance when taking the bees out of the tree. If I want the trap to have just one entrance, I’ll seal up the second one from the beginning.

      I didn’t consider it for ventilation purposes, but considering how I keep the trap sealed up it would help this situation. My rectangular trap hives are in fact designed to take frames. You could put two different entrances on yours if you want to do that. Consider the size of your first entrance to help make this decision.

      --Tom

      Delete